Skip to results

Fall Hallmark Movie Round Table (with Ryan Asher)

#201standardBizarre Niche
Nov 6, 2025·1h 3m
Watch Episode on YouTube ↗
Premise: It’s getting chilly out and you know what that means! The perfect pairing to the perfect fall day is a crisp walk among the leaves, a PSL, and getting cozy on the couch with a fall Hallmark movie! This week on the podcast we meet the team behind the Hallmark movie Fall in Love. We hear from them on the process behind the movie from start to finish, including how such a wonderful script was written, what made this one lightly different from the others, and how they tackled the complex emotional life of these characters. So sit back, get your hot chocolate ready, and enjoy this one-of-a-kind discussion.

Cast & Characters (5)

Bits & Timeline (18)

1:16ESCALATION
1:52

Hallmark Plus: The Human Touch Subscription

The panel discusses the unique benefits of Hallmark Plus, which includes a physical 'human touch' service where representatives visit subscribers' homes to hug their candles and rotate them on the couch.

"What are they missing? The people that subscribe to Hallmark more than anything else. It's human touch."

"I'll hug your candle. I'll hug your cat. I'll hug anything."

"We'll rotate you on the couch that you haven't moved from."

3:09CHARACTER_INTRO
4:11

Roundtable Roll-Call: The Hallmark Veterans

The cast introduces themselves, featuring a director who only works with Will.i.am and a whimsical actress named Patricia Dawn Ft. Dean whose name is a military base legacy.

"They call me Fincher for the snow globes."

"My great-grandfather started Fort Dean, the military base, and the name stuck."

"If just like the leaves change, you need to change, too."

7:21TABLE_BREAK
2:53

Sal Valentine's Apple Orchard Conspiracies

Sal Valentine, the resident heartthrob, derails the conversation with method acting stories and a conspiracy theory that 95% of apples are synthetic government-hidden frozen props.

"We are not eating real apples. We're eating synthetic apples."

"I went method for this. I went to an orchard five times this year."

"The fact that you deep fry your pamphlets is really impressive."

10:15TABLE_BREAK
2:53

Melinda Scarf's 'Slot' Directions and Free the Hole

Writer Melinda Scarf explains her script-writing process, which includes 'slot' directions for actresses and a movement to 'free the hole' as the next step after freeing the nipple.

"My scripts are mostly stage directions."

"Why did we start going up the ladder if we weren't going to eventually go to hole?"

"The glass ceiling right there. There's a woman's hole right there."

14:41CHARACTER_INTRO
3:55

Mary St. Peters: The Toasty 34

Mary St. Peters reveals she is working with a 'cast' of MIT scientists to preserve her age at a 'toasty 34'—an approachable, non-intimidating level of hotness.

"I am working with some scientists to preserve me at exactly a toasty 34."

"A toasty that's not going to hurt the roof of my mouth."

"I can't have a gif out there of me saying poop."

19:30TABLE_BREAK
2:26

The Prepositional Preponderance of Hallmark Titles

The panel discusses the sheer volume of Hallmark movies they've produced, leading to a list of increasingly absurd titles like 'Autumn and Even' and 'Snow Globe Trotters' where everyone dies inside a snow globe.

"You kind of went through all the preposition of love."

"Autumn and Even. Two math teachers falling in love."

"When all the globe trotters got stuck into that snow globe. They couldn't get out and they died in there."

24:10GAME_OR_PITCH
1:15

The Turnpike vs. Autumnsville Meet-Cute

A clip from the film 'Fall for Love' shows a high-stress New York City woman clashing with a local leaf-orchard owner in a 'violent' meet-cute involving a bucket of leaves and the word 'Loca'.

"I want to go back to being a slut!"

"You might as well be speaking Spanish to me. And I only know one word. You're pretty Loca."

"I'm from the turnpike where you can go into a bar and you send an email to your friends."

26:40CALLBACK
1:30

Harry's Stunning Instagram Content

The conflict between Mary and Melinda escalates as Melinda admits to obsessively watching Mary's husband's Instagram for ten hours a night to fall asleep, specifically praising his shirtless surgery photos.

"If I'm going to fall asleep, I need to look at your husband's Instagram for 10 hours at least."

"Harry is always doing things with his shirts off when he shouldn't be. Surgery."

"Wear your scrubs. You're a doctor."

31:51TABLE_BREAK
1:56

The Tragic Apple Picking Head-Plucking Incident

Melinda reveals the film is based on her real life, specifically the tragic day her sister's head was accidentally picked off by someone who thought it was a large apple.

"When my sister died tragically in the apple picking accident."

"Someone picked her head right off."

"I thought it was an apple. I swear."

39:30TABLE_BREAK
2:42

The Three-Minute Monologue and Snapchat Filters

The panel discusses a deleted scene from their Hallmark film that was shot entirely using a Snapchat filter where the actor barfs rainbows. Melinda Scarf performs a long, dramatic monologue about her dead husband Richard.

"The summer stays hot, the winter stays cold, the fall stays changing."

"We shot this on that Snapchat filter where you barf rainbows."

44:04TABLE_BREAK
1:21

Hallmark's Gun-Based Budgeting

The writers and actors reveal the high-pressure environment of Hallmark, claiming 95% of the budget goes toward guns used to threaten writers into finishing scripts in five minutes.

"95% of their budget goes to guns."

"Get in the basement and write it. You have five minutes."

45:25BACKSTORY_REVEAL
0:02

The Showmance and BuzzFeed Quizzes

Mary and Sal discuss their brief 'showmance' on set, which ended because Mary's BuzzFeed quiz results suggested she was a 'Monica' rather than a 'Rachel.'

45:27TABLE_BREAK
2:03

Melinda's List of Loves and Political Platforms

Melinda Scarf lists the things she loves, ranging from puppies to sucking dick by the 7-Eleven, and promotes her political platform: 'Make Kids Hot Now.'

47:31VISUAL_GAG
0:59

The Magic Pumpkin Reveal

Melinda and Mary find common ground and forgive each other, leading to the reveal that Melinda's breasts look like magical orange pumpkins.

"I forgive you."

59:30ESCALATION
0:21

Hall Milk and Bible Jokes

The panel discusses the unfortunate branding of 'Hall Milk' and Sal makes a brief, confusing attempt at a 'Bible joke' by identifying as John.

"It sounds like milk from outside the hall."

"And I'm John. Bible joke."

59:51TABLE_BREAK
1:14

The Two-Minute Hate Monologue

Mary St. Peters performs a rapid-fire list of things she hates, including inny belly buttons, maroon carpet, and everyone named Sherry.

"I don't think I've been happy in a day in the last 10 years."

"Everyone named Sherry."

"I hate Radio Disney."

1:01:05VISUAL_GAG
1:15

The Shrinking and Death of Mary St. Peters

Mary begins to shrink physically while listing things she loves, eventually dying and returning as a ghost to repeat her three-minute monologue.

"Moho got smaller. The mic's getting bigger."

"Just like all good Hallmark movies, she ended with goodbye."

"Now you're a ghost. Does one of us have to fall in love with you?"

1:02:21TABLE_BREAK
1:19

Goodnight Hollywood and Merch Plugs

The hosts break character to wrap up the episode, plug guest Ryan Asher's social media, and promote their new podcast merchandise.

"Now that's why we call it show business. Good night, Hollywood."

"Joker took our website. Bye."